important: this list is no longer up-to-date. Check http://www.mobfd.com/ 

This record is almost certainly wrong and incomplete. Please do correct me by sending me a link to a comment that is higher/lower than the ones listed here: Werttrew99@yahoo.com

In the summer of 2009, there was a new policy where only registered commenters could vote. This immediately caused vote totals to plummet, but they have steadily grown to current levels.  Asterisks denote a comment that was pre-commenters-only-voting rule. I’ve not included them in the ranking, but I’m listing them for posterity’s sake.

Eventually, when I’ve had you kind folks correct my gaps and mistakes, I’ll list the actual comments themselves. For now, I’m just putting in the link to the posts where the original comments can be found.

Most upvoted and downvoted comments ever.

Upvoted  (Votes as of October 23, 2010)

1. Chareth Cutestory 437 http://videogum.com/198561/the-videogum-why-dont-you-caption-it-contest-the-ladies-of-the-daily-show/franchises/why-dont-you-caption-it/

***Dictums 418 http://videogum.com/80742/spoiler_alert_new_moon_has_a_t/spoilers/

2. Patrick M 344 http://videogum.com/227142/dear-outsourced-please-kill-yourself/tv/new-tv-shows/ 

***ModernMANDroid 341 http://videogum.com/73821/monsters_ball_the_weeks_best_c/franchises/monsters-ball/

***Ladders 285 http://videogum.com/78932/this_is_your_music_video_confi/music-related-content/

3. Huckabeast 274 http://videogum.com/213172/the-videogum-why-dont-you-caption-it-contest-jay-z-hugging-gwyneth-paltrow/franchises/why-dont-you-caption-it/

***MusclesMarinara 260 http://videogum.com/74381/megan_fox_please_understand_me/top-stories/

***Godsauce 250 http://videogum.com/81091/gwyneth_paltrows_recipe_for_ro/top-stories/#comment-4358702/ 

4. werttrew 242 http://videogum.com/222052/the-unfortunate-return-of-the-hunt-for-the-worst-movie-of-all-time/franchises/the-hunt-for-the-worst-movie-of-all-time/

5. abalogariz 218 http://videogum.com/189492/the-videogum-why-dont-you-caption-it-contest-sad-keanu-reeves/franchises/why-dont-you-caption-it/

6. werttrew 206 http://videogum.com/212921/videogum-dare-name-a-movie-that-looks-worse-than-love-and-other-drugs/movies/trailer/

***K-Mo 194 http://videogum.com/79912/videogums_teen_korner_new_moon/franchises/teen-korner/

7. Thisismynightmare 191 http://videogum.com/237351/the-videogum-why-dont-you-caption-it-contest-luke-perry-at-dragon-con/franchises/why-dont-you-caption-it/

8. wrj713 188 http://videogum.com/194752/best-new-party-game-26-do-you-mean-the-one-where/franchises/best-new-party-game/

***dude 179 http://videogum.com/81302/a_brave_california_woman_solve/webjunk/viral-video/

9. Jordan Schlansky 175 http://videogum.com/182422/the-videogum-why-dont-you-caption-it-contest-xavier-beauvoiss-cool-new-t-shirt/franchises/why-dont-you-caption-it/

10. Notsewfast 173 http://videogum.com/165611/the-hunt-for-the-worst-movie-of-all-time-down-to-you/franchises/the-hunt-for-the-worst-movie-of-all-time/

Most downvoted comments ever (votes as of Oct. 1)

5. thegreatsatan -86 http://videogum.com/201332/birdie-falls-asleep/cute-as-balls/birdie-cute-as-balls/

***HB -87 http://videogum.com/74922/monsters_ball_the_weeks_best_c_1/franchises/monsters-ball/

4. Mr. Hausfrau -88 http://videogum.com/219282/monsters-ball-the-weeks-best-comments-26/franchises/monsters-ball/

3. garbage_face -89 http://videogum.com/176962/the-birdie-report-hi-birdie/top-stories/

2. laughcamp -91 http://videogum.com/204841/we-all-win-this-dance-battle/webjunk/viral-video/comment-page-1/#comment-7635322

*** TalbainJ2: TalbainJ Harder -92 http://videogum.com/81332/monsters_ball_the_weeks_best_c_4/franchises/monsters-ball/

***buenosueno -93 http://videogum.com/78862/monsters_ball_the_weeks_best_c_2/franchises/monsters-ball/

***buenosueno -104 http://videogum.com/74922/monsters_ball_the_weeks_best_c_1/franchises/monsters-ball/

1. Godsauce -106 http://videogum.com/166451/the-videogum-why-dont-you-caption-it-contest-sean-hannity-is-a-feminine-hygiene-product/franchises/why-dont-you-caption-it/